You have already classified the sweep as a Judas. This asks the next question: is it a good one? Nine weighted criteria — the sweep, the reclaim, the evidence, and the context. Weights are not equal, because the evidence is worth more than the location. The thresholds below are a starting hypothesis, not a measured result — grade your own setups, log the outcomes, then move the lines to fit your data.
Weights encode a claim worth stating plainly: the reclaim, the displacement and the structure shift carry 2 points each because they are evidence the market produced; the sweep locations carry less because they are only where you were watching. A setup can score 6 on location and context alone and still be untradeable. Direction shown for a bullish Judas — mirror every term for the bearish case.